When you’re shopping for a cedar fence, you might assume that “cedar is cedar.” Unfortunately, that’s not the case, and it’s costing homeowners thousands of dollars in unexpected repairs and replacements.
At Thomas Fence, we’ve noticed a troubling trend in our local market: some fence installers are substituting inferior cedar species for Northwest Arkansas wood fences without telling customers. You might think you’re getting a premium Western red cedar fence, but you could end up with Chinese cedar that won’t last half as long.
Let’s clear up the confusion so you can make an informed decision about your fence investment.
The Three Types of Cedar You’ll Encounter
Western Red Cedar (WRC): The Gold Standard
Western red cedar is the premium choice for outdoor fencing, and for good reason. This North American native species boasts a rich, reddish-brown color and warm grain, instantly adding curb appeal to your property. But looks aren’t everything.
What really sets WRC apart is its exceptional natural durability. The wood contains natural oils that resist decay, insects, and moisture damage. With proper installation and minimal maintenance, a Western red cedar fence can last 20 to 30 years or more.
Best suited for homeowners seeking a long-term investment with minimal upkeep and maximum durability.
Japanese Cedar (Sugi): The Middle Ground
Japanese cedar, known as Sugi in its native Japan, offers a lighter brown color, fine grain, and smaller knots. It’s an attractive, budget-friendly option that costs 20-30% less than Western red cedar.
However, there’s a trade-off. Japanese cedar has moderate decay and insect resistance, but not the excellent natural protection of WRC. With regular maintenance (staining, sealing), you can expect 10 to 20 years of life. It may also be more prone to warping or twisting, especially in lower grades.
At Thomas Fence, we’re transparent about this option. Japanese cedar sits between treated pine and Western red cedar in terms of quality and price. It’s a solid choice if you’re budget-conscious and willing to commit to regular maintenance.
Best for cost-conscious homeowners who don’t mind extra upkeep and are planning for a shorter fence lifespan.
Chinese Cedar: The Shortcut Some Competitors Take
Here’s where things get concerning. Chinese cedar (Cunninghamia lanceolata) is the least expensive cedar option, and some installers use it without disclosing this to customers.
Chinese cedar has pale yellow to light brown coloring with larger knots and inconsistent grain. More importantly, it has low to moderate decay and insect resistance, making it the most prone to warping, twisting, and deterioration. Even with regular maintenance, expect a lifespan of only 8 to 15 years.
The problem: Some fence companies advertise “cedar fencing” without specifying the species. Customers assume they’re getting premium Western red cedar, but they’re actually getting the cheapest option at premium prices.
At Thomas Fence, we never use Chinese cedar for our Northwest Arkansas wood fences. We believe in transparency and quality.
How to Protect Yourself When Shopping for a Cedar Fence
Ask the Right Questions
Don’t just ask if the fence is “cedar.” Ask:
- What specific species of cedar will be used?
- Is it Western red cedar, Japanese cedar, or something else?
- Can you provide documentation or certification?
Look at the Wood Grain and Color
If you’re inspecting samples or your completed fence:
- Western red cedar: Rich reddish-brown with warm, consistent grain
- Japanese cedar: Light brown with fine grain and smaller knots
- Chinese cedar: Pale yellow to light brown with larger knots and an inconsistent appearance
Check the Aroma
Cedar species have distinctive scents:
- Western red cedar: Sweet, earthy cedar aroma
- Japanese cedar: Fresh, floral scent
- Chinese cedar: Mild, less distinct cedar scent
Get It in Writing
Make sure your contract specifies the exact species of cedar. If a company won’t put it in writing, that’s a red flag.
The Thomas Fence Difference
At Thomas Fence, we only use two types of cedar for Northwest Arkansas wood fences: Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) and Western red cedar (Thuja plicata). We’ll never surprise you with an inferior product.
When you call us for an estimate, we’ll explain the differences between these two options, show you samples, and help you choose the right cedar for your budget and long-term goals. You’ll know exactly what you’re getting before we install a single post.
Our Recommendation
If your budget allows, Western red cedar is the clear winner. Its superior durability, natural resistance, and beautiful aging make it the best long-term investment. You’ll spend less on maintenance and won’t need to replace your fence for decades.
If you’re working with a tighter budget, Japanese cedar is a legitimate middle-ground option, provided you understand the maintenance requirements and its shorter lifespan. We’re completely transparent about these trade-offs.
What we’ll never do is use Chinese cedar or mislead you about what you’re getting.
Your Fence Is a Major Investment: Protect It
A fence isn’t just a property line; it’s a significant investment that affects your home’s value, curb appeal, and security. You deserve to know exactly what you’re paying for. Before you sign a contract with any fence installer, ask about the cedar species they use. If they can’t or won’t give you a straight answer, keep shopping.
At Thomas Fence, we believe in honesty, quality, and treating our customers with respect. That starts with giving you all the facts about your fence options.
Ready to discuss your cedar fence options? Use our instant estimator for a free estimate. Contact us online or call us at (479) 636-4732 today, and we’ll walk you through your choices so you’ll know exactly what you’re getting.
